Preference shares can look attractive when you want more certainty than ordinary shares may offer, without moving all the way to lending money to a company. They can give an investor priority for dividends, repayment of capital, or both. For business owners, they can also be a useful way to bring in capital while preserving different economic or voting rights for founders and investors.

The important word is “priority”. Preference shares do not automatically guarantee an income stream or protect an investor from loss. Their real value, and their real risk, depend on the specific rights written into the company’s constitution or approved on issue.

What preference shares are and how they differ from ordinary shares

A preference share is a class of share that has rights ahead of another class, usually ordinary shares. The priority may relate to dividends, repayment of capital, surplus assets on a winding up, or a combination of these matters.

Under Australian company law, the rights attached to preference shares must deal with matters such as:

  • repayment of capital;
  • participation in profits and surplus assets;
  • whether dividends are cumulative or non-cumulative;
  • voting rights; and
  • priority of capital and dividend payments relative to other share classes.

This means there is no single, universal “preference share” investment. Two companies can both issue preference shares, yet give their investors very different rights.

Ordinary shareholders generally participate in the upside and downside of a company after any priority rights have been met. Preference shareholders may receive a defined dividend entitlement before ordinary shareholders receive anything. In return, they may have more limited voting rights and less opportunity to share in the company’s long-term growth.

For example, an ordinary shareholder may benefit more if a company becomes highly profitable and increases dividends substantially over time. A preference shareholder may instead have a fixed or formula-based entitlement, which can provide greater income visibility but may cap participation in extra profits.

The company’s constitution, share terms and any offer or subscription documents are therefore more important than the label attached to the shares.

How priority dividends can work

A preference dividend is not simply a dividend paid early. It is a contractual or constitutional right that establishes the order in which distributions are dealt with between different share classes.

A common arrangement is that preference shareholders are entitled to receive a dividend before ordinary shareholders can receive one. However, the exact entitlement should answer several practical questions:

  • Is the dividend fixed, variable or linked to a formula?
  • Is it payable only if directors declare it?
  • Is it cumulative or non-cumulative?
  • Does it rank ahead of every ordinary share, or only some classes?
  • Can the preference shareholder participate in additional dividends after receiving the preference amount?
  • Is the dividend capable of being franked?
  • What happens if a dividend is missed?

Cumulative preference shares can be particularly important for income-focused investors. If the company does not pay a preference dividend in one period, the unpaid amount may accumulate under the share terms and become payable ahead of future ordinary dividends.

That does not necessarily mean the investor can demand immediate payment. The precise legal effect depends on the terms of issue and the company’s ability to lawfully pay a dividend. A cumulative right can improve an investor’s position relative to ordinary shareholders, but it does not create cash where the company has none.

Non-cumulative preference shares work differently. If a dividend is not declared or paid for a relevant period, the entitlement may lapse rather than carry forward. This can be a materially higher risk for someone relying on the investment for regular income.

A company may only pay a dividend where its assets exceed its liabilities by enough to cover the dividend, the payment is fair and reasonable to shareholders as a whole, and it does not materially prejudice the company’s ability to pay creditors.

In practical terms, even a well-drafted preference dividend right cannot override the company’s financial position or its obligations to creditors.

Why preference shares may reduce some risks, but not all risks

Preference shares can reduce particular risks when compared with ordinary shares. They do not eliminate investment risk.

The most obvious benefit is payment priority. If the company has sufficient capacity to pay a dividend, preference shareholders may receive their entitlement before ordinary shareholders receive a dividend. Similarly, on a winding up, preference shareholders may have priority for repayment of capital or surplus assets over ordinary shareholders, depending on their terms.

However, creditors are generally ahead of shareholders. If a company fails and its assets are insufficient after secured and unsecured creditor claims are dealt with, preference shareholders may still lose some or all of their investment. The fact that a shareholder has priority over ordinary shareholders does not make them equivalent to a lender or secured creditor.

Other key risks include the following.

  • Business performance risk: If the company performs poorly, it may not be able to pay dividends or redeem shares.
  • Capital loss risk: The value of the shares can fall, particularly where there is no active market for them.
  • Liquidity risk: Shares in a private company can be difficult to sell. An investor may be unable to exit when they want to.
  • Redemption risk: A redeemable preference share may only be redeemed according to its terms of issue. Redemption may also depend on the company having sufficient profits or new share issue proceeds available for that purpose.
  • Inflation and opportunity-cost risk: A fixed preference dividend may become less attractive if market returns or inflation rise.
  • Limited control risk: Preference shares may have restricted voting rights, leaving investors with limited influence over management decisions.
  • Terms-change risk: Share class rights can sometimes be varied or cancelled through processes set out in the company constitution and company law. Investors should understand the protections available before investing.

The right way to view preference shares is as a risk-shaping tool, not a risk-free investment. They may reduce the risk of being paid after ordinary shareholders, but they do not remove the risk that the company cannot pay at all.

The main types of preference share terms to review

Before buying preference shares, investors should read the governing documents closely. For a small or private company, this may mean reviewing the constitution, shareholders agreement, subscription agreement and the formal terms of issue.

Several terms deserve particular attention.

Cumulative or non-cumulative dividends

This determines what happens when a preference dividend is not paid. A cumulative entitlement may preserve the unpaid amount for future periods. A non-cumulative entitlement may not.

This distinction can have a major impact on the reliability of expected income.

Participating or non-participating rights

A participating preference share may allow the holder to receive the priority dividend and then share further in company profits or capital distributions.

A non-participating preference share may be limited to its stated priority entitlement. This can make the investment more income-focused, but it may reduce upside if the company grows strongly.

Voting rights

Preference shareholders may have voting rights in all circumstances, only on certain resolutions, or only where their rights are affected. Investors should not assume they will have the same ability as ordinary shareholders to appoint directors or influence business strategy.

For a business owner raising funds, voting rights need careful design. Giving investors priority returns while retaining ordinary voting control may be commercially useful, but it must be clearly documented and understood by everyone involved.

Redemption and conversion rights

Redeemable preference shares can be issued with redemption at a fixed time, on a stated event, at the company’s option or at the shareholder’s option.

A conversion feature may allow preference shares to convert into ordinary shares on a future event, such as a sale of the business, capital raising or agreed date. Conversion can provide upside potential, but the conversion formula should be carefully tested before the shares are issued or acquired.

Ranking on an exit or winding up

The terms should state clearly where the preference shares sit relative to:

  • secured creditors;
  • unsecured creditors;
  • other preference share classes;
  • ordinary shares; and
  • any shareholder loans or convertible instruments.

This is particularly important for startups, family businesses and companies with multiple investor groups. A seemingly simple preference share arrangement can become complicated where several classes of shares, shareholder loans and external finance facilities exist.

Tax considerations for Australian investors and business owners

Tax treatment should not be an afterthought. The legal label “preference share” does not always settle the Australian tax outcome.

Where a company makes a franked distribution, the general tax rules include the franking credit in the recipient’s assessable income and provide a tax offset equal to that credit, subject to the relevant eligibility, residency and integrity rules.

For an individual Australian resident investor, this commonly means the cash dividend and associated franking credit need to be considered in the income tax return. The final tax outcome depends on the investor’s broader taxable income, deductions, available offsets and eligibility for the franking credit.

Not every preference dividend will be franked. A company needs available franking capacity, and the distribution must be capable of being franked under the tax law. An investor should not assume that a stated dividend rate means a fully franked cash return.

For trusts, the treatment can be more complicated. The way a dividend and its franking credit are allocated among beneficiaries depends on the trust deed, trustee resolutions and the operation of the tax rules. Trustees should obtain advice before acquiring or distributing income from preference shares.

For SMSFs, preference shares can be an allowable investment in some circumstances, but the fund’s trust deed, investment strategy, diversification, liquidity needs and related-party rules all need attention. An SMSF should not invest in shares issued by a related private company without specialist advice.

Business owners also need to consider the tax character of the instrument they are issuing. Australian tax law looks at economic substance, not merely legal form, when distinguishing debt interests from equity interests. An interest that is treated as debt for tax purposes may have different consequences for deductibility and franking than an equity interest.

That is one reason why preference share terms should be reviewed before documents are signed. A fixed return, redemption obligation, conversion feature or other commercial promise can change the tax analysis.

A practical example for a growing business

Imagine a profitable Australian company that wants to raise funds for expansion without immediately giving new investors equal voting control.

The founders hold ordinary shares. An investor is offered preference shares with a priority dividend, limited voting rights and a right to repayment of capital ahead of the ordinary shareholders if the company is wound up. The shares may also convert into ordinary shares if the company is sold.

This structure could suit both sides. The investor may receive greater priority than ordinary shareholders for dividends and capital, while the founders retain greater control over day-to-day decisions.

But the investor still needs to ask whether the company has reliable cash flow, whether dividends are cumulative, how redemption will be funded, whether the shares are transferable and what happens if the company needs additional capital later. The founders need to consider company law, tax treatment, valuation, shareholder relations and the impact on future fundraising.

The value of the arrangement lies in the detail, not the name of the share class.

Key questions to ask before investing or issuing preference shares

Whether you are an investor, company director or existing shareholder, consider these questions before proceeding:

  • What is the exact dividend entitlement and when does it arise?
  • Is the dividend cumulative if unpaid?
  • Is the dividend expected to be franked, partly franked or unfranked?
  • What priority applies on a sale, winding up or return of capital?
  • Do creditors, shareholder loans or other preference classes rank ahead?
  • Are the shares redeemable, convertible or transferable?
  • Who controls the timing and terms of redemption?
  • What voting rights does the holder have?
  • Can the company issue more shares that rank equally with, or ahead of, the existing preference shares?
  • Can the rights be varied, and what approval is required?
  • How will the investment be taxed for the investor and the company?
  • Does the investor have a realistic exit path?

Preference shares can be a flexible way to balance income priority, capital protection and company control. They may be useful for investors seeking a different risk profile to ordinary shares, and for Australian business owners looking to raise capital without using a simple ordinary-share structure.

The priority attached to preference shares can be valuable, but it is only as strong as the company’s finances and the legal terms behind it. Before investing or issuing a new share class, it is worth getting the structure, records and tax treatment reviewed carefully.

This article is general information only and is not personal financial, legal or tax advice. Speak with a registered tax agent or accountant, such as, about your circumstances before investing in or issuing preference shares.